Summary of Section 37C of the Pension Fund Act (Retirement Annuity Beneficiaries)

Section 37C of the Pension Fund Act ensures that death benefits from a retirement fund are distributed by the fund’s trustees, overriding other laws and the deceased's will. The High Court and Pension Fund Adjudicator confirm that trustees' discretion is paramount, even over customary law.

Applicability of Section 37C

Section 37C applies to benefits arising from membership in a retirement fund, payable upon the member’s death. This includes benefits from pension funds, provident funds, and preservation funds before retirement but excludes personal annuities.

Key Provisions of Section 37C

• Distribution Process: Benefits must be distributed to dependants within 12 months, or to nominees if no dependants are found. If both exist, an equitable distribution is made between them.
• Dependants Definition: Includes individuals legally or factually dependent on the member, like spouses, children, and others receiving regular support.
• Nominees: Individuals nominated by the member to receive benefits. Nominations must be in writing and communicated to the fund.
• Payment to Minors and Majors: Minor beneficiaries typically receive benefits through guardians or trusts. Major beneficiaries can receive lump sums or annuities.

Taxation and Legal Considerations

• Taxation: Lump sums are taxed in the hands of the deceased, while annuities are taxed as income for the recipient.
• Constitutionality: There are debates on whether Section 37C limits testamentary freedom, but it ensures benefits support the deceased's dependants.

Practical Implications

• Estate Planning: Financial planners must account for Section 37C in estate planning, ensuring clients understand that retirement fund benefits are not directly controlled by their wills.
• Liquidity Issues: Benefits may not contribute to estate liquidity, potentially causing shortfalls in meeting liabilities.

Conclusion

Section 37C prioritizes dependants' maintenance over the deceased’s testamentary intentions. Financial advisors must educate clients on these implications for effective estate planning.

‍